Ecology/Environment posted in the Korean Catholic Times 'Our Common Home' Earth: Why Must We Continue This Fight? Written by a professor and the president of the Earth Law Society.
The ecological movement does not continue because there is a guarantee of success; rather, it endures long retreats and failures because there is an awareness of why this struggle must continue.
In *The Essence of Struggle: An Ecological Revolution Against the Myth of Growth and Technological Totalitarianism*, French political ecologists Bernard Charbonneau and Jacques Ellul state, “The audience that listens to the voice of ecology is very small. People merely worry and do not move toward the radical choice of confronting the causes of acid rain.” They then recall the following maxim often attributed to William of Orange, the leader of the Dutch War of Independence (Eighty Years' War, 1567–1648) against Spanish Habsburg rule.
"There is no need to hope. Just plan and act. There is no need to succeed. Just persevere."
William of Orange, who led a rebellion to break free from the oppression of the Spanish Empire—the most powerful nation of the time—realized that immediate victory was impossible. Instead of acting rashly based on short-term hopes and falling into despair, he chose a strategy of long-term endurance and persistence. His tenacious resistance, in which he acted persistently without being fixated on the outcome despite being at a disadvantage in power, eventually led to the independence of the Netherlands.
The essence of this maxim lies not in denying hope, but in maintaining an attitude of persistence, even when success is not guaranteed.
Viktor Frankl’s *Man’s Search for Meaning* demonstrates that the meaning and purpose of life can serve as an inner strength that endures extreme situations. In the era of the global climate crisis, what meaning and purpose of life does humanity need?
In *The Principle of Hope*, Ernst Bloch conceived of hope not as vague optimism or consolation, but as a practical force that moves individuals and society toward a better world that has not yet arrived but remains open as a possibility
Professor John Cobb, an ecological philosopher who passed away in 2024, once said that the only task remaining for humanity is the struggle to preserve the foundation for reconstruction while preventing the situation from worsening. The ecological movement does not continue because there is a guarantee of success; rather, it can endure long retreats and failures only when there is an awareness of why this struggle must continue.
Even William of Orange, who said “there is no need to hope,” must have had a reason for resisting Spain. Responsibility toward those innocently exposed to the climate and ecological crisis, future generations, non-human species, and nature as a whole compels us to act, even in the face of the possibility of suffering and catastrophe. Therefore, we must continue this fight not because we are optimistic about a better world, but because we cannot abandon our responsibility.